Your Colorado Home’s Historic Woodwork Deserves a Second Life: The Art of Restoration Over Replacement
When you walk through a Colorado home built in the early 1900s, there’s something magical about running your fingers across the original wood trim, feeling the weight of history in every grain. But what happens when years of paint buildup, scratches, and wear have dulled that natural beauty? The question facing many Colorado homeowners today isn’t just about aesthetics—it’s about preserving the soul of their home while making practical financial decisions.
The Character Dilemma: Why Original Wood Matters
Historic homes from around 1900 possess historical integrity worth saving, and hardwood floors and trim in these homes are often made from old-growth wood, which is denser and has a grain pattern that you cannot find in newer wood, telling a story through each scratch and stain. Once original material is removed, it is gone forever, and property owners serve as stewards of historic homes for only a short time.
Woodwork like baseboards and trim can be easily updated and restored, adding the perfect amount of character throughout any home, helping strike the perfect balance between modern and historic. Refinishing allows you to maintain the character and charm of your original hardwood floors, which can be particularly valuable in older homes, and can significantly boost the appeal and value of your home.
The Colorado Climate Challenge
Colorado’s unique climate presents specific challenges for wood preservation. Colorado’s 300+ days of sunshine create UV exposure that fades standard paints 40% faster than coastal climates, and when combined with hailstorms, temperature swings, and freeze-thaw cycles, standard paints fade 40% faster in Colorado’s climate. This makes the decision between refinishing and replacing even more critical for Colorado homeowners.
The wood that is already in place is well acclimated to the home, and any new growth wood you may install as new moldings may or may not hold those perfect trim joints you make, depending on the quality and type of wood you use and how much attention you pay to moisture content and seasonal conditions.
When Refinishing Makes Financial and Emotional Sense
Refinishing a hardwood floor is generally less expensive than replacing the entire hardwood floor and preserves the original charm and unique characteristics of the hardwood floor. Refinishing is significantly cheaper than replacing because you’re working with what you already have, which means no need to buy new materials, and depending on the size of your space and the type of wood, refinishing can save you thousands.
The environmental benefits are equally compelling. Refinishing minimizes the amount of material discarded as the existing wood is preserved, and involves less manufacturing and transportation of new materials. By reusing your existing floors, you’re reducing waste and the environmental impact associated with manufacturing and transporting new materials.
For homeowners considering wood refinishing services, professional expertise becomes crucial. Hiring professionals who specialize in historic preservation or who have experience working with historic homes is crucial, as these experts can navigate the challenges of preserving old wood, matching historical finishes, and ensuring that the refinishing process enhances the home’s historical value.
The Art of Professional Wood Refinishing
Professional Wood Finishes Larimer County services understand the delicate balance required for historic preservation. Heavy sanding removes the patina (the natural aged look which gives antique wood its character), so proper refinishing techniques are essential. Certain modern hardwood refinishing techniques and products should be avoided in historic homes, as water-based polyurethane may not be suitable for older wood floors as it can sometimes alter the wood’s natural color and texture, and aggressive sanding techniques can risk removing too much surface material.
Even if everything is not stripped perfectly, it will still look clean, it will look like it belongs, and it will be full of character instead of clean and sterile like the new stuff. The goal isn’t perfection—it’s preservation with character.
When Replacement Becomes Necessary
While refinishing often wins the day, there are situations where replacement becomes unavoidable. Replacement is necessary for floors with structural damage like water damage or subfloor problems, severe wear and tear such as deep scratches, warps, or termite infestation, or floors that have been refinished several times to the point where more refinishing is not possible.
In some older homes, the base trim was applied directly to the beams, then the lath and plaster was run down to the base trim, making removing/replacing that base trim a costly endeavor due to the damage that usually results to the plaster.
Working with Colorado’s Trusted Professionals
LF Rosa Painting brings over a decade of experience to Northern Colorado’s unique restoration challenges. As a Fort Collins and Northern Colorado painting business specializing in interior and exterior painting for homes and commercial buildings, with over ten years of experience, they understand the importance of color in your space. Their painters understand that painting is more than changing the color of your walls—it’s about changing how you and your family feel in your home, and they take pride in their workmanship, using the best equipment paired with skills and experience to make your painting project a stress-free experience.
Having spent 15 years perfecting their approach to Colorado’s unique challenges, LF Rosa Painting understands that remodeling and preserving a historic home takes a lot of time, patience, and expertise, which is why it’s crucial to invest in help from reputable professionals that are proven historic preservation contractors.
Making the Right Choice for Your Home
The decision between restoring and replacing comes down to more than just dollars and cents. Historic wood has been there a hundred years and could be there 100 more if left in place, with the current property owner serving as steward of the house for only a short time. Refinishing hardwood floors in historic homes is more than just a renovation project—it’s a preservation effort that requires a thoughtful approach and specialized skills, and choosing the right professionals to handle refinishing can make all the difference in maintaining architectural integrity and continuing the legacy of cherished homes.
When you choose to restore rather than replace, you’re not just saving money—you’re preserving a piece of Colorado’s history while creating a home that honors the past and serves the future. In a state where character and authenticity matter as much as mountain views, that decision becomes about much more than wood and stain. It becomes about home.